Mark Duncan is a 49-year-old driver who has worked in the formal private sector for more than two decades. Yet, like many of his peers, he has never joined a private pension plan. Of course, he contributes to the National Insurance Scheme (NIS) and the National Housing Trust (NHT), but that’s where his savings end.
“If my retirement contributions were as automatic as NIS and NHT and were deducted before I get my little pay, I wouldn’t feel it,” he admits. “I’d just accept that I have a benefit waiting when the time comes to retire.”
That simple statement captures a truth that behavioural scientists and policymakers around the world have recognised for years: people are far more likely to save when they do not need to make a decision about it – the decision is automatically made for them.
Habit vs Sacrifice
Behavioural economist Stephen Shu notes that automation “turns saving from a painful act of discipline into a background behaviour that simply happens.” This helps explain why workers in countries with automatic savings mechanisms tend to remain enrolled once the process begins; it becomes a habit that feels effortless rather than a sacrifice.
This principle lies at the heart of the Pension Industry Association of Jamaica’s (PIAJ) proposal for the introduction of pension auto-enrolment. The proposal has already received the green light from the Ministry of Finance and the Public Service, and Cabinet submissions are now being prepared.
“Pension auto-enrolment gives us a real chance to reduce the coverage gap and ensure that more Jamaicans, especially those in the formal private sector, begin saving from day one,” said Constance Hall, director of the PIAJ. “This reform could more than double the number of Jamaicans saving for retirement within a decade.”
Benefits of Auto-Enrolment
Auto-enrolment makes saving for retirement simpler and more accessible. Instead of having to take extra steps to join a pension plan, employees are automatically enrolled through their workplace and begin building retirement savings immediately. Participation remains entirely voluntary, which means anyone who prefers not to stay in the plan can choose to opt out at any time.
“Auto-enrolment changes behaviour without removing choice,” Hall explained. “It helps people do what they already know they should, start saving early.”
Hall pointed to the success of countries that have already implemented auto-enrolment. “Countries that introduced this reform are now reaping the benefits: a stronger savings culture, reduced elderly poverty, and lower pressure on government welfare systems,” she said. “Jamaica can follow that path through legislation that encourages saving and secures the financial well-being of our people.”
In the United Kingdom, participation in workplace pensions rose from 47 per cent in 2012 to over 88 per cent by 2018, according to the Department for Work and Pensions. Only about nine per cent of automatically enrolled employees opted out—proof that once workers start saving, they rarely stop. Similarly, New Zealand’s KiwiSaver now covers nearly 75 per cent of the working population.
Under the PIAJ’s proposal, all workers in the formal private sector would be automatically enrolled in a registered pension plan through their employer.
Contributions would be deducted from salaries and remitted to a licensed pension administrator, similar to how income tax or NIS deductions are handled. There would be no mandatory employer contribution requirement, and implementation would be phased, beginning with medium and large employers before gradually expanding to cover the wider workforce.
Employees would still have the right to opt out; however, international experience shows that once auto-enrolment is introduced, most people choose to stay in. In countries where this system has been implemented, opt-out rates typically range between 10 and 30 per cent.
Today, less than 20 per cent of Jamaica’s 1.44 million labour force contribute to a private pension plan, according to data from the Financial Services Commission and the Statistical Institute of Jamaica.
The PIAJ is urging policymakers to move swiftly on the legislative changes required to make auto-enrolment law.
Article via:
